Conquering the Gutter: Choosing the Best Eavestrough Style for Your Home

Posted August 15, 2024

Eavestroughs, also known as gutters, are the unsung heroes of your home’s exterior. These often-ignored heroes play a vital role in protecting your foundation and roof from water damage.  But with various styles and materials available, selecting the right eavestrough can feel like navigating a maze.  Fear not, homeowner!  This guide will equip you to choose the eavestrough style that will keep your home happy and dry.

The Contenders: A Rundown of Eavestrough Styles

  • K-Style: The reigning champion of popularity, K-style eavestroughs boast a sharp, angled design that adds a touch of style to any home. They’re deeper than traditional half-round styles, allowing them to handle larger volumes of water. Formed on site, K style is the most cost effective way to install it.
  • Half-Round: A classic contender, half-round eavestroughs offer a simple, rounded shape. While not as deep as K-style, they can be a good choice for smaller homes or areas with less rainfall. Most half-round styles can be purchased in low quantities 10 foot sections at a time either plastic or metal. Because of this, it is often more expensive than K-style.
  • Box Style: Often used commercially, box style eavestroughs offer a sleek, modern look. They can be a good choice for contemporary homes or large warehouse type buildings but may not be suitable for all architectural styles.
  • Multi profile: a new generation of machines offer 3 new profiles, although 2 of them are really similar to the champion, K-style, the 3-step profile does have a sleek design. The only drawback being it handles less water and has a narrow bottom. A big disadvantage considering only a small square downspout can be installed as opposed to the industry standard of a large square. It is not recommended for all roof types.

Choosing the right size:

  • 5 inch: the industry standard since the early days, 5 inch replaced previous models such as 4 or even 3 inches. It handles most rainfalls and blends in nicely with most residential houses.
  • 6 inch: 5 inch is sleek but has its limit. With today’s crazy weather, when it rains, it pours. Sometimes a larger alternative is needed. Previously thought to be used only for commercial application, nowadays, it’s often used for residential. The design, style of the roof will determine if this is an option.
  • 7 inch and above: often done in sections with a box style profile, this type of eavestrough is mostly used for commercial applications. It is custom made and way more expensive than traditional K-style formed eavestroughs.

Downspout discussion:

An eavestrough system is nothing if it can’t evacuate the water it collects. The design of the house often dictates where a downspout can be located. A rule of thumb is 1 per 20-40 feet depending on the twist and turns.

  • 2×3: This size is almost non-existent as it was replaced with the industry norm, 3×3 large square.
  • Small square 2.5×2.5: this type of downspout is mostly used for multi-profile eavestrough as the base of it is 2.5’’. A larger option could not fit.
  • Large square 3×3: the champion of the downspouts. The 3×3 funnels a large amount of water. In addition, it allows small debris to flow through the opening. Being the industry standard, many colors are available.
  • 3×4: often paired with 6’’ eavestrough, this is an ideal size for large volume of water or lack of downspout drops. The colors available are limited to popular colors.
  • 4×5: most often used for commercial applications, this is the largest size available for 6’’ eavestrough; it is too big for 5’’. The only downfall is the color options are really limited and the price is excessive. It really serves a specific situation when downspout drops are limited.
  • Box style: Just like the eavestrough, this application is custom made piece by piece and is often reserved for commercial applications. It’s really more expensive than traditional prefabricated products.

The Judgement: Deciding Factors for Your Dwelling

Choosing the best eavestrough style hinges on a few key factors:

  • Roof Pitch: Steeper roofs generally shed water more efficiently, so half-round eavestroughs might suffice. Shallower roofs may benefit from the increased capacity of K-style eavestroughs.
  • Rainfall Amount: Areas with heavy rainfall benefit from the larger capacity of K-style eavestroughs.
  • Aesthetics: Consider the architectural style of your home. K-style eavestroughs offer a more modern look, while half-round styles suit classic aesthetics. Box style eavestroughs can complement contemporary homes.
  • Maintenance: All eavestroughs require cleaning to prevent clogs. However, K-style eavestroughs might be slightly easier to clean due to their wider opening.

Bonus Round: Material Matters

While style is important, don’t forget about material! Here are popular eavestrough materials to consider:

  • Aluminum: A lightweight, affordable option that’s resistant to rust and corrosion. It is the champion of material that is formed on site with special machines.
  • Steel: A highly durable option that can withstand even harsh weather conditions. It is typically reserved for custom box eavestrough and downspout. Because of this, it is highly expensive.
  • Vinyl: Another affordable option that’s easy to maintain. However, vinyl eavestroughs may not be as durable as aluminum or steel. It often cracks and is typically reserved for do it yourself type of situation.

The Final Quest: Finding Your Perfect Eavestrough Solution

Armed with this knowledge, you’re well on your way to selecting the best eavestrough for your home.  Remember, the ideal choice depends on your roof pitch, rainfall amount, desired aesthetics, and budget.  Consulting a qualified contractor can provide valuable insights and ensure proper installation for optimal performance.

So, step out of the gutter of confusion and embark on your quest for the perfect eavestrough!  Your home (and foundation) will thank you!